Module 1Module 2Module 3Module 4Module 5Module 6

Ohio Reference Excellence on the Web from Ohio Library Council
Ohio Reference
Excellence
Ohio Library Council
Module Module 4
Introduction 4
Search strategies
Patron sources
Subjects & terms
Indexing
Look it up
Accuracy
Asking experts
Info & Referral
Referrals
 Keeping track
Inform patron
Review 4
Quiz 4
Answer 4
About ORE
Home
Purpose
Instructions
Contact OLC
Contact SLO
Print Choices
Supervisor Tips
Copyright-Credits
Site Index
All Modules
Module 1   Overview
Module 2   Interview
Module 3   People
Module 4   Strategies
Module 5   Resources
Module 6   Ethics

Keeping Track

For every reference transaction, list the resources used.

Keep a Record of Your Search

     Throughout the reference process, keep track of the questions, the information you gathered in the interview, and the sources you've tried. Keep track of anything that might help you, another staff member, or another library to continue work on the reference transaction if the question is referred.

     When you are working on complicated searches you should make note of the books and online resources you use. Also note the subject headings you use in working with indexes and the inclusive dates of the indexes you check. List the specific titles you use. Do not record a statement like "all the books here" or "all our antique books," in case the question must be referred to another library. Call numbers may not be helpful at the next level either, but the author's last name and the book's title should be enough to identify the source for most purposes.

Use a Form

     If your system has a form for referring questions to second level reference, you may wish to use the form from the beginning with each reference question. This has several advantages:

  • If you are interrupted, you can pick up where you left off without duplicating work.
  • Patrons appreciate knowing where you have looked, even if the search was not successful.
  • If you find you need to refer the question, you MUST tell your central library or reference center where you searched.

Official Counts of Reference Transactions

     Depending on your library's practice, you may also need to keep track of the number of questions (transactions) as well as the resources used. A reference transaction is "an information contact that involves the use, recommendation, interpretation, or instruction in the use of one or more information sources, or knowledge of such sources, by a member of the reference or information staff."

[In Definitions of a Reference Transaction, the RUSA Board of Directors adopted the definition relevant to reference and adult services contained in American National Standard for Library and Information Statistics (ANSI Z39-1983).]

What's Not a Transaction, and Why It Matters!

     A directional transaction involves directing a patron to specific places or items in the library. All library staff should be able to distinguish and contrast a reference transaction from directional transactions in order to keep better statistics on library activity. Statistical measures are important as indicators of service to your community. Although statistics alone do not measure the activity in your library or its importance, statistical measures can help in evaluating current services and may impact planning (and budgeting) for new services.

Transaction Tracking in Virtual Reference Service

     The virtual reference technology and forms used may provide automatic ways to capture transaction information. Frequently asked questions have special value, not just for keeping track, but in building databases to be used when answering repeated questions and building FAQs to assist patrons. However, special consideration must be given to patron privacy and confidentiality:

  • Reference transactions may be used in the creation of databases and FAQs but care should be taken to maintain the privacy of patrons and the confidentiality of patrons' inquiries.
  • Beyond removal of patron identifiers, inclusion in a database should not compromise patron confidentiality, and this should be evaluated when choosing questions for inclusion in a database.
  • Patrons should be informed, through publicly available policy, that their questions might be included in a database. They should be provided a means to request removal of their inquiries from the database.
  • Data gathered and maintained for training purposes and for publicizing the service should also protect patron confidentiality.
[Guidelines for Implementing and Maintaining Virtual Reference Services, Section 5.3]

Major Point: Keeping track of your search helps others who may work on the search and helps in planning future services. Questions kept with virtual technology may be used to build a database or create FAQs.

 

Exercise

  1. Study the form that your library uses to keep track of reference questions.
  2. Are there areas on the form for describing the question resulting from the reference interview, listing sources checked, noting when patron was informed, referral status, and citation of the source where answer was found?
  3. Does your library keep track of reference questions all the time or at certain times of the year? What are the statistics used for?

Answers

Next!
Inform patron

 

 

Keep track of resources consulted: others may work on the question later, or data may be used to evaluate services. Questions may be used to build databases and FAQs for virtual reference.

Ohio Libraries

Keep track of all reasources, for every patron.

Transactions can be counted, but the satisfaction of finding just the right thing for special people can't be measured! [Chris Anders]

Some library services aren't reference transactions or directional transactions!

And some transactions just can't be measured! [Happy the Clown at Miami Township Branch Library]

Learn More!

Do you want to Learn More about reference transactions?

Ohio Questions

bulletred.gif (894 bytes) A female college student asked for a biography of Jackie Kennedy. When given the book with "Onassis" on the cover she asked, "Oh, is that her maiden name?" If you've forgotten, Bouvier was Jackie's maiden name!

Web Links

 MORE (Minnesota Opportunities for Reference Excellence) site offers reference question worksheets that would be helpful in keeping track of transactions for these subjects:
Medical
Legal
Vehicle Repair
How-to-do-it
Poetry
Quotation
Song
Art
Antiques and Collectibles
Groups and Associations
Personal Names
Biographical
Bibliographic Verification
Periodical Article Request
Pay-per-search Electronic Search

You are here: OLC > OREModule 4 > Keeping Track
Module 1  Module 2  Module 3  Module 4  Module 5  Module 6
Home | Purpose | Instructions | Contact OLC | Contact SLO
Print Choices | Supervisor Tips | Copyright-Credits | Site Index
ORE on the Web, Ohio Library Council, 2000-2007.
See Copyright-Credits page for information regarding design, source of materials, and for use of the site.
Return to top